Price Guide
All cake orders are pickup or delivery only, sugar cookies can be mailed with shipping cost added (Cost depends on the amount and distance- generally around $10). Pick up times will be verified at the time or order, and an additional $15 per half hour (30 mins) will be added as a late fee to any late pickups.
Our sugar cookies can be mailed!
Specialty Cake Pricing
Our custom cakes are the perfect centerpiece at any event. With fluffy, moist layers and a tart fruit filling, or a velvety mousse center, these cakes are sure to impress even your most picky guests.
Please note:
​
*Pricing is determined by the size, number of tiers, and decorations added. This is just the base pricing, which includes basic icing decorations with a preset flavor. Pricing can increase with added decor and custom flavors.
Base pricing*:
​
Single Tier Cakes
(3 layers)
Smash Cake (4")- $25.....Serves 4
6"- $90...........................Serves 16
8"- $120..........................Serves 28
10"- $145.........................Serves 36
​​
Two Tier Cakes
4"/6"-$115......................Serves 20
6"/8"- $180.....................Serves 42
6"/10"- $225....................Serves 48
8"/10"- $300...................Serves 62
​​
Three Tier Cakes
4"/6"/8"-$300.................Serves 48
6"/8"/10"- $350...............Serves 85
8"/10"/12"- $400.............Serves 112
​
Four Tier Cakes
4"/6"/8"/10"- $375...........Serves 92
6"/8"/10"/12"- $450.........Serves 128
​​​
Tall Cakes- Single Tier
(5 layers)
4"- $40...........................Serves 8
6"- $105..........................Serves 24
8"- $135..........................Serves 32
​
​
​
​
Custom Cookies
Our decorated sugar cookies are made fresh for each order, and prepared with royal icing that does not include egg whites, so you can snack on your cookies even longer.
$65 per dozen
The cookies come individually wrapped and packed in a standard box with tissue paper between each layer.
​
Add a colorful ribbon to your wrapping for a fanciful addition to your packaging.
Wedding Cakes
With lots of options and transparent pricing, our wedding cakes have become one of our best selling products at our bakery. Your big day shouldn't be one filled with stress, so let the professionals handle the big stuff. Here at Misfits Bakery, we pride ourselves on being affordable, dependable, and outright delicious. Fill out our wedding form to choose your options and discuss your vision with our amazing team.
​What's included?
- A tasting with up to 6 flavors. (Additional flavors are available for $5 each)
- A design consultation with our head baker herself so you can share your vision and ideas
- Handmade sketches with an unlimited amount of tweaks and remakes
- A hand painted framed sketch of your wedding cake as a gift to you on your wedding day
- A free 4" anniversary cake on the one year mark of your wedding date (day subject to change due to availability)
- Drop off and set up at the venue, pickup of any items being returned to us
​
Pricing for wedding cakes follows our pricing for any other cake (located in specialty cake pricing section above)