Specialty Cakes
Our specialty cakes are expertly handcrafted to each occasion, and bursting with unique and unforgettable flavor. Let us know your theme, colors, and design preferences and let us do the rest with our freestyle design options or tailor every detail by consulting on sketches with our bakers.
Pricing
Our custom cakes are the perfect centerpiece at any event. With fluffy, moist layers and a tart fruit filling, or a velvety mousse center, these cakes are sure to impress even your most picky guests.
Please note:
*Pricing is determined by the size, number of tiers, and decorations added. This is just the base pricing, which includes basic icing decorations with a preset flavor. Pricing can increase with added decor and custom flavors.
Base pricing*:
Single Tier Cakes
(3 layers)
Smash Cake (4")- $25.....Serves 4
6"- $90...........................Serves 16
8"- $120..........................Serves 28
10"- $145.........................Serves 36
Two Tier Cakes
4"/6"-$100......................Serves 20
6"/8"- $180.....................Serves 42
6"/10"- $225....................Serves 48
8"/10"- $300...................Serves 62
Three Tier Cakes
4"/6"/8"-$300.................Serves 48
6"/8"/10"- $350...............Serves 85
8"/10"/12"- $400.............Serves 112
Four Tier Cakes
4"/6"/8"/10"- $375...........Serves 92
6"/8"/10"/12"- $450.........Serves 128
Tall Cakes- Single Tier
(5 layers)
4"- $45...........................Serves 8
6"- $120..........................Serves 24
8"- $145..........................Serves 32
@asmanaman, 2026
"I just have to DM you!!! I work at Tompkins, today I had the most devine cookie I have ever had that my coworker brought in of yours. It was so refreshing to eat a cookie that tasted this good!"
Hannah Hall, 2025
"I got my wedding cake from Misfits Bakery and I literally could not have been more pleased! Caty was very easy to work with when planning, and on the day the cake arrived on time, looked beautiful, and tasted great. We've literally been eating leftover cake for 2 weeks and it still tastes good! Nothing but good things to say here :)
Benson, 2025
“I could not ask for something better. From the initial call to ask questions to all the help I was given afterwards, I am very happy with Misfits Bakery. I was late getting a cake ready, and normally they ask for 1 week notice, but I was at 6 days and was still helped. Their service and care are amazing. The cake was stunning and was better than what I was hoping for. I wanted funfetti and was accommodated for. We got the almond vanilla and even after 3 days in the fridge (we waited for the actual birthday to eat it), it was still moist and flavorful. I 100% recommend Misfits Bakery to anyone looking for a custom cake. Oh, and the price is very fair and definitely worth the value. Thank you so much!”
